And the 42nd Interim SMC Board Member…


… is also being joined by the 43rd and 44th. I am very proud to report that Aaron Strout, Coach Deb (Deb Micek) and Chris Hambly were the top vote getters with 383 for Aaron, 340 for Deb and 179 for Chris (who barely edged out Maddie Grant who had 166).

Why did we decide to expand to 44 from 42? It is simple. No one wanted to do a run off and have to go shill for votes all weekend - and that certainly wasn’t what I intended it to be. So, this morning I asked the interim board what we should do. By a narrow margin, we determined we should simply ask the top three vote getters if they were ok with bringing them all into the interim board and they agreed. In fact, seeing Deb and Aaron joke about it in the comments is what persuaded me this morning.

Unfortunately, there were some technology troubles: the corporate proxy servers prevented some of the candidate’s supporters from voting at work (so sorry); there were intermittment failures to accept votes in the last hours and probably four or five more problems with using Democracy Poll for an attempt at democracy. More importantly, we learned an important requirement of our member community software, which we will be designing collaboratively. We really need a good community system with one member, one vote software and special discussion pages for discussing the merits of the candidates of our formal organization and for the local groups.

Still, I think the overall effort was a success in demonstrating we really are going to be an open organization that will remain unwavering in our commitment to fairness and serving the greater needs of the Social Media community / industry. There was some good discussion about whether we should sustain the process we originally outlined so as to show that we keep our word. I think it is more important to respect the people inside the process and to admit mistakes, make corrections and move on to whats important.

To that end, it was never our intention to use this election process as a link building exercise. The original 41 were selected upon three critiera - merit, willingness to contribute a few hours each month and trust. I chose people I know who really understand what is happening in social media, would commit to contributing (more then just attention) and share some of the key values we hold (despite disagreeing with some of them on other topics). Some were members, others woud have been if I asked (or could have gone through the formality of signing up for a free Open Membership).

To be clear, my intention here is to get Social Media Club organized and heading in the right direction for the benefit of the community. It is to ensure the values of openness, honesty and willingness to engage in the conversation remain at the core of what we do and what we promote. It is to get other people than myself engaged, activated and working on behalf of our common cause. It is to get Social Media Club running as a self-sustaining community organization, being lead by other self-directed people who want to do good and are willing to work with others in the community to do more good together.

So the bottom line here is that we really want this to be an organization, of, by and for the people who share an interest in social media and its “greater significance.” The election was an attempt at an open democratic process. By agreeing to expand the size and skip the run off is just one other such example of listen, consider, converse and act, then repeat.

I for one, am very glad we did this process as I got to meet a bunch of new people who are doing good work in Social Media. We also accomplished some goals, we learned a lot, we picked up some momentum and we are getting a chance to grow. We also ended up with what seems to be three really great social media professionals, which is ultimately a wealth of riches more then we could have hoped for.

We have a lot of work to do from here, which we will begin blogging about on Monday. Though several interim board members are already underway on projects.

In the mean time join me in welcoming Aaron Strout, Coach Deb and Chris Hambly. I am looking forward to working with each of you.

PS - We will be doing something more with the other 35 folks nominated as well as those who paid for CoFounder memberships. One of the first tasks of the interim board is to consider how it is being structured, the language we are using and dividing up the work on the things we want to get done.

Update: corrected spelling of Chris Hambly’s last name

Share it...
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati
  • YahooMyWeb
  • Facebook
  • Google
  • Ma.gnolia
  • TwitThis
Sphere: Related Content

Information and Links

Join the fray by commenting, tracking what others have to say, or linking to it from your blog.


Other Posts
Social Communications?
Vote for the 42nd Interim Board Member

Our Friends

arrows450.jpg
SMC members receive $200 off the registration fee - use promo code ESM08SM

BlogWell: How Big Companies Use Social Media - October 28th - San Jose, CA

We Vote Badges - Undecideds

SU2C

Categories

Pages


Write a Comment

Take a moment to comment and tell us what you think. Some basic HTML is allowed for formatting.

Reader Comments

AWESOME choices. Congrats to all three of you!

Have you closed the comments on the previous post? I couldn’t post there so posted here instead.

Good to see someone not just from the US/Canada voted in.

Such a shame that it became a trivial voting process with people tweeting and sending people over to vote for one of the nominees.

It really took away from the potential influence and reputation of the Social Media Club with people voting for people based on someone having friends who Tweet for you and not on real merit or the contribution they are making at the moment in the world of social media.

No wonder some of the significant influencers in social media did not put themselves forward. There are so many people I can think of making a contribution to social media across the globe but why on earth would they want to put their name forward and ten be embarrassed with few voters.

And as for then moving the goal posts to not just having 1 person nominated but 3 - well that sums up the process as a sham.

Whatever we say about the US Presidential elections at least they are more robust than this process.

How disappointing.

Lucy - we didnt close the comments on the previous post.

You are right though, there are so many people doing great work in social media around the world - many of which don’t have time to contribute. So how do you choose 3 of them to serve on a board? How do you choose 12? Should we choose 3 or 12 or 15 or 41 or 44? Who has the power to choose? you? me? Why sets the rules and who corrects the rules when they are not working in an emergent organization that is in transition?

Any person doing good work in social media has friends here who will be glad to help them move their good work forward. Armchair quarterbacks have great perspective when things are said and done but not much to contribute to the process of leading, of risking something or of trying to do something and realizing you made some mistakes.

Lucy, I am sorry we disappointed you by listening to other members of the community who have a differing opinion than you, but I am not sorry for the choices made or the fact that we have a good result.

BTW - I am keeping my word here - I asked all along (in each post or the comments) for suggestions on improving the process and I heard them and we improved the process.

Well done Chris,

Also, congratulations to all, I’m looking forward this, and more importantly, meeting the “tribe” virtually and physically.

Also, I have no “e” in my name, though a common mistake.

:)

WOW!

How cool that Aaron and I had the power to “persuade” the board backed by our loyal tribe who supported us via social media.

I humbly accept the nomination & plan to make a continued contribution of the people by the people in regards to social media.

{Acceptance Speech here}

Thank you all for your support & helping to get the word out about this Social Media Club via “social media”.

The love and support and campaigning for me by my tribe has overwhelmed me so much that I’m adding this entire “social media experience” in the Twitter Handbook so others may learn the power of social media.

Interesting note:
While I was tempted to send an email out to my list of clients, I never did because I wanted to keep this an experiment of just how much could be influenced through social media alone. Namely - one source - Twitter.

It taught me so much that, win or lose, I planned on writing a post on my blog about it over on http://TribalSeduction.com I’ll work on it over the weekend, b/c I have MUCH to say b/c - quite frankly - I’ve learned SO much all throughout the process.

Thanks to Aaron for really making me “work for it”. I enjoyed my lead on the 1st day while it lasted, and glad it motivated those who really wanted this position to get out there and work for it.

And if I may offer one more attempt at persuading the board - to bring on a 45th member as: Maddie Grant. She sure worked it - telling me - she knows how to move social media. That’s impressive in my book.

PS: I’ve also met a lot of fantastic new friends through this process - namely Chris & Aaron as they responded to comments & sent me DM’s on Twitter.

Those of you who I haven’t met yet - send me an @ msg so I can be sure to add you on TWitter

http://Twitter.com/CoachDeb

Congratulations to all. Granted I wasn’t in the top 3, but for a Canuck I wasn’t last :)

Note that I’m able to help in any capacity that I can.

Thanks to Chris, the other super smart/cool/savvy 41, and all the folks that took the time to vote for me.

Also, congrats to Coach Deb and Chris Hambly (no “e”). I look forward to working with you both along with the rest of the board.

Best,
Aaron | @astrout

Just want to say a special thanks to those who voted for me for Social Media Club Board’s #42, and I remain really passionate about helping SMC grow. Congrats to those who got the seats.

This was BIG FUN and I think there was some excitement to it that hopefully got more than just me excited! Thank you Deb for your vote of confidence, it really means a lot! And I know I’ll participate even if I can’t be on the board - social media is all about sharing and collaboration, is it not! Huge congrats to all three of you, and I’m amazed that I got so close despite being such small fry. Rock On!!

Congrats to the winners!